Supply chain coordination using optimal transfer pricing to balance co- and byproduct demand within a process industry

Abstract: Process industries has for long been important for the development of Swedish industry and society. All industries face different conditions that affect how to best run their operations. This thesis aims to describe some of the conditions that characterize process industries compared to other industries. Further one of these characteristics has been studied more closely.One of the traits of process industries is that they are positioned at the start of the transformation process close to the raw material mixing, separating or forming it into products often used for further transformation. Process industries hence become dependent on the properties of these materials. One of the most prominent characteristics inherent from the raw material properties is the divergent bill of material. The divergent bill of material originates from the fact that a given raw material is made up of different components that will yield several products with different characteristics when processed. When splitting the raw material into the desired products the yielded products from a certain raw material usually have different value to the producer, some more desired than others. These multiple products generated poses a challenge from a planning perspective raising questions like “How should we balance the supply and demand of all the products produced?”, “What shall we do with the excess products produced?”.The first paper in this thesis describe the production planning in four Swedish process industries with the ultimate aim to connect their planning to the supply chain characteristics they face as process industries. The study concludes that the industry specific conditions mainly affect planning at short time ranges when planning becomes more detailed. In general the use of planning or decision support systems is low, stemming from a, warranted or not, belief that general decision support systems do not fit process industries. Another finding is that the case companies mainly operate in niche markets. This study also highlighted that the planning complexity arising from characteristic of co- and by-product generation in combination with the lack of decision support systems requires further studies.The subsequent two papers focus on supply chain planning and coordination with a divergent bill of material. They present a mathematical model over the supply chain planning in a real case company in the specialty oils industry. The second paper investigates transfer pricing as a coordination tool by comparing decentralised supply chain planning with centralized planning in an integrated model. Transfer pricing is found to have a potential positive effect on supply chain planning while simultaneously creating problems in terms of uneven  distribution of the contribution margin among supply chain partners.Finally the third paper more closely investigates different ways to set transfer prices and comparing them to the optimal transfer prices. Setting optimal transfer prices with a divergent bill of material has proven to be less straightforward than the case with no dependencies between products. Some optimal transfer prices could even be set lower than the marginal cost for producing them due to the dependency between the products in the divergent bill of material. This indicates that there is an opportunity cost for a product that is dependent on the demand of other products.