Analysis of Human Brain MRI Contributions to Regional Volume Studies

Abstract: Many disorders are associated with regional brain volumes. The analysis of these volumes from MR images often requires sequential processing steps such as localization and delineation. It is common to perform volumetric normalization using intracranial volume (ICV, the total volume inside the cranial cavity) when comparing regional brain volumes, since head size varies considerably between individuals. Multiple methods for estimating ICV and procedures for volume normalization exist.A method for interhemispheric surface localization and extraction, using both intensity and symmetry information and without time consuming pre-processing, was developed. Evaluations of hemisphere division accuracy as well as suitability as a pre-processing step for interhemispheric structure localization were made. The performance of the method was comparable to that of methods focusing on either of these tasks, making it suited for use in many different studies.Automated ICV estimations from Freesurfer and SPM were evaluated using 399 reference segmentations. Both methods overestimated ICV and estimations using Freesurfer contained errors associated with skull-size. Estimations from SPM contained errors associated with gender and atrophy. An experiment showed that the choice of method can affect study results.Manual ICV estimation is very time consuming, but can be performed using only a subset of voxels in an image to increase speed and decrease manual labor. Segmenting every nth slice and stereology were evaluated in terms of required manual labor and estimation error, using the previously created ICV references. An illustration showing how much manual labor is required for a given estimation error using different combinations of n and stereology grid spacing was presented.Finally, different procedures for ICV normalization of regional brain volumes when investigating gender related volume differences were theoretically explained and evaluated using both simulated and real data. Resulting volume differences were seen to depend on the procedure used. A suggested workflow for procedure selection was presented.Methodological contributions that can aid the analysis of the human brain have been presented. The performed studies also contribute to the understanding of important methodological considerations for regional brain volume analysis.